I love Elin Hilderbrand...which pains me to write this honest personal review:
Not a Swan Song, more like a Turkey Screech.
I was really disappointed in Swan Song. I've liked so many of Elin's books and always looked forward to them.
The last few have injected politics into the fray, which totally distracts from the story.
And it's as if her last book (supposedly final book, though she admits in the acknowledgements it might not be her last....The Tom Brady of Fiction?) she thought, "well, if I'm going out, might as well inject all my political ideals into the book!
We had to slog through environmentalism, racism, lesbianism, inter-racial couples, and painting Southern upbringing as typical backwoods, backwards, blue collar, stupid people.
But it's not like any of those topics helped the story or fit, it's as if she was using those topics to say, "Look how elitist and progressive I am!"
She also had explict sex scenes which I don't remember in any of her previous books. And though there were only a few, WHY? A good author is able to leave details to the imagination of the reader.
Once she got passed the progressive notes, the book turned into a delightful usual Elin novel. We focused on the characters, their drama, and things were going well in the middle of the book, and then it turned the last few chapters.
Extremely rushed.
The characters became caricatures.
The ending was neatly wrapped up in three pages.
Super disappointed.
I usually can't put her books down...this one I put down so many times at being put off by the various things I mentioned, and then literally rolled my eyes at the ending.
If you're a die hard Elin fan, by all means, you'll love it.
If you are a discerning reader that dislikes tropes, skip it and choose any book of Elin's but Swan Song...
